Both block ads. Both run on your home network. Both are free. So why does the adguard home vs pi-hole question still come up in every homelab forum, every week, without a definitive answer? Because they’re genuinely different tools that happen to solve the same surface-level problem — and which one is right for you depends almost entirely on what you want from a DNS-level blocker.
I’ve run both. Pi-hole for two years, then AdGuard Home for eight months, and I can tell you exactly what I noticed switching between them. This isn’t a spec sheet comparison — it’s what the difference actually feels like to use day to day, and when each one makes more sense.
AdGuard Home vs Pi-hole: The Fundamental Difference
The adguard home vs pi-hole comparison starts at the architecture level. Pi-hole is a DNS sinkhole — it intercepts DNS queries and blocks the ones matching your blocklists. AdGuard Home does the same thing, but it’s also a full DNS server with encrypted DNS support (DoH, DoT, DoQ) baked in natively, per-device filtering built into the UI, and a service-blocking feature that lets you toggle off entire platforms (TikTok, Discord, YouTube) with a single switch.
Pi-hole is older, has a massive community, and integrates with everything. AdGuard Home is newer, more modern in its architecture, and does more out of the box. Neither is objectively better — they’re optimized for different homelab philosophies.
Pi-hole: The Community Standard
If you’ve run Pi-hole before, you know the appeal. It’s been the default homelab DNS blocker for years, which means the community around it is enormous. There are blocklists for everything, integrations with every router firmware, Docker images that have been battle-tested by thousands of people, and a forum where almost every problem you’ll encounter has already been solved by someone else.
Pi-hole v6 (released in 2025) completely rewrote the internals — removed the old PHP/lighttpd dependencies, embedded a new web server directly into the FTL binary, and added a native REST API. It’s significantly lighter and easier to maintain than earlier versions. The web UI is functional, though it feels dated compared to AdGuard’s interface.
Where Pi-hole shines: blocklist management, custom DNS rules, and the depth of community support. If something breaks, someone has already fixed it. If you want a specific integration, there’s probably a script for it.
AdGuard Home: The Modern Challenger
The adguard home vs pi-hole gap is most obvious at install time. AdGuard Home ships as a single binary — no web server to configure separately, no PHP dependencies, just download, run, and it’s working in about three minutes. Native DoH, DoT, and DoQ support means you can set encrypted upstream DNS resolvers directly in the UI without touching a config file. That’s a meaningful quality-of-life difference if you care about DNS privacy.
The killer feature is per-client filtering. You can set different blocklists for different devices — your kids’ iPad gets a strict content filter while your work laptop gets minimal blocking. In Pi-hole, this requires custom group management that’s functional but inelegant. In AdGuard Home, it’s three clicks.
The service blocker is also genuinely useful: toggle a switch to block all traffic to YouTube, TikTok, WhatsApp, or Discord at the DNS level — great for parental controls or for giving yourself a distraction-free work mode.
What to Run Them On
Both tools run happily on nearly anything — a Raspberry Pi, a spare laptop, a VM inside Proxmox, or a Docker Compose stack. For a dedicated DNS server with low power draw, the Beelink EQ14 is overkill in the best way: it handles DNS blocking plus ten other services at 6–8W idle. If you want a true dedicated single-purpose device, a Beelink EQ12 Pro at this task barely uses any of its capacity.
Both tools have official Docker images and run identically well in containers. If you’re already running Pi-hole in Docker, switching to AdGuard Home is just a different image name in your Compose file.
Beelink EQ14 Mini PC, Intel Twin Lake N150 (4C/4T, Up to 3.6GHz) Mini Desktop Computer, 16GB DDR4 RAM 1TB SSD, Dual HDMI 4K 60Hz, Dual 2.5G LAN, WiFi6/BT5.2/WOL, W 11 Home for Business/Office
- 💡【Compact Size & Blazing Smooth Performance】The Beelink EQ14 mini pc packs an Intel Twin Lake N150 (4C/4T, max 3.6GHz) and pre-installed W 11 Home, delivering snappy performance for daily tasks, this Beelink mini desktop computer saves desk space, ideal for light office work. Effortlessly handle Zoom/Skype meetings, run Office/PS, surf the web and stream videos simultaneously. Perfect for office, online education, home entertainment and industrial use
- 💡【Storage Expansion】The Beelink EQ14 mini pc comes with 16GB DDR4 3200MHz RAM (single-channel, max 16GB) and a 1TB PCIe 3.0 SSD. It features dual M.2 slots: one M.2 SATA3 2280 and one M.2 PCIe 3.0 x1 (NVMe), supporting up to 8TB total internal storage (retail unit includes NVMe SSD). High-speed storage ensures smooth multitasking and fast data access
- 💡【 Intel Graphics & Dual HDMI Output】 The Beelink EQ14 mini pc features Intel Graphics (24EUs, 1000MHz) that supports crisp 4K video playback and smooth web surfing. Its dual HDMI ports let you connect two monitors simultaneously, boosting multitasking efficiency for office work, streaming, and more.
- 💡【Versatile I/O & Wireless Connectivity】The Beelink EQ14 mini pc boasts rich I/O ports: 2*HDMI ports, 2*2.5G LAN ports, 3*USB 3.2 ports, 1*USB 2.0 ports, 1*type-c port(data). It supports dual 4K displays via HDMI. Built-in WiFi6 (802.11ax, AX101, dual-band 2.4/5GHz) and BT5.2 ensure stable signals with strong anti-interference.
- 💡【Reliable Lifetime Service】We have been devoting to the production and R&D of Mini PC. Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions. We offer lifetime technical support, 3-year worry-free warranty, and 24 hours customer service.
Beelink EQ12 Mini PC, 12th Gen Intel-N100 (up to 3.4GHz), 16GB DDR5 RAM 500GB PCle3.0 SSD, Mini Desktop Computer Support 4K@60Hz/Triple Display/WiFi6/BT5.2/Type-C/Dual 2.5Gbps LAN
- ✅【Upgraded Intel-N100 Mini PC】— Intel Alder Lake-N100 features 4 CPU cores, 4 threads, max turbo clock of 3.4GHz, Intel UHD Graphics 24EUs, and 6MB L3 smart cache. Compared with the Intel Jasper Lake N5105 CPU, its performance has been improved by more than 25%. CPU-N100 adopts intel 7 manufacturing process, the standard TDP of the processor is 6W. This is an entry-level office mini computer that can also be used as a NAS and soft router.
- ✅【Max 16GB RAM and 2T PCle 1xSSD】—Beelink EQ12 Mini PC features a single SODIMM slot, which supports DDR5-4800MHz RAM of up to 16GB. It also comes with an M.2 2280 slot for PCIe/SATA3 SSD storage (up to 2TB), and a SATA3 interface for a 2.5-inch SATA HDD/SSD (up to 2TB). EQ12 PC is a “4.25 x 4.01 x 1.54” inches small form factor desktop PC. The mini PC employs a plastic chassis enhanced by deep laser engraving, making it resistant to scratches.
- ✅【Triple 4K Display and Upgraded Cooling systeam】—The Intel UHD GPU delivers powerful graphics performance. Dual HDMI and Type-C allow you to multitask efficiently on two 4K@60Hz displays. It also supports AV1 decode. EQ12 N100 Mini PC supports a large silent CPU fan, a copper heat sink, and a dedicated SSD cooling shield. The upgraded cooling mechanism is much better than the N5105 mini PC
- ✅【Wifi6/BT5.2 and Dual 2.5GbpsLAN】—Beelink EQ12 N100 equipped WiFi6 (600Mbps) and BT5.2, enables fast data transfer to meet your daily use needs. Beelink Intel N100 mini pc ports: 2*2.5Gbps LAN Port, 2* HDMI, 3*USB3.2(10Gbps), 1*Type-C. Office, Design, Home Video, and other software all run smoothly and meet all your daily needs and work. The Dual Gigabit LAN design allows the EQ12 mini pc to double as a soft router and a home TV box.
- ✅【7*24-hour support and 1 Year Warranty】—All Beelink Mini PC have passed CE, EMC, FCC, and RoHS certifications. Beelink mini pc additional functions: Wake up On LAN, PXE, Power-on function set in BIOS. If you have any product-related questions Or consult before buying, please contact support. We have 24-hour after-sale team support and provide one year warranty.
AdGuard Home vs Pi-hole: Which Should You Pick?
Here’s the adguard home vs pi-hole decision framework that saves you from second-guessing later:
Pick Pi-hole if: you want the broadest community support, you’re already deep in the homelab ecosystem and want integrations everywhere, or you’re comfortable doing some manual configuration for encrypted DNS.
Pick AdGuard Home if: you’re setting up DNS blocking for the first time, you want encrypted DNS out of the box, you need per-device filtering with minimal friction, or you want to use service blocking for parental controls or focus modes.
The Takeaway on AdGuard Home vs Pi-hole
In the adguard home vs pi-hole debate, there’s no wrong choice — both block ads effectively and both are free. Pi-hole wins on community depth and ecosystem breadth. AdGuard Home wins on out-of-the-box features and ease of setup for newcomers.
If you’re brand new to homelab DNS blocking: start with AdGuard Home. It’ll be running in five minutes and you’ll be impressed. If you’re already a Pi-hole user with a working setup: there’s no compelling reason to switch unless per-device filtering or native encrypted DNS is something you need. Either way, running network-wide DNS filtering is one of the highest-ROI things you can do with a home server — once it’s running, you won’t think about it again.
Which one are you running? Or thinking of switching? Drop it in the comments.